Sustainable Mining and Metallurgy journals implement online submission and review. All papers in this journal strictly implement peer review in the form of blind review, as follows.
1. The principle of peer review
1 ) We should adhere to the principles of fairness, justice, confidentiality and timeliness ;
2 ) the review of the manuscript only in the academic evaluation, not to make evaluation and personal attacks on individuals ;
3 ) Respect different academic views and resolutely resist academic misconduct.
2. Evaluation of expert responsibilities
1 ) Fill in the review comments on the review papers on time, and feedback to the editorial department within the specified time. Due to delays caused by objective factors, the editorial department should be informed in a timely manner.
2 ) Discovering academic misconduct in papers, we should truthfully feedback to the editorial department, and not make rude, derogatory or objective comments ;
3 ) If the research direction is not familiar with or there is a conflict of interest to make an objective evaluation of the paper, you can avoid review.
4 ) All review comments and information must be confidential, not for personal use, not to others to circulate, discuss, not to use and publish the review of the manuscript data, views, conclusions, if you want to use, must obtain the consent of the author.
3. Peer review content
The experts in peer review of this journal mainly objectively and fairly evaluate the innovation, practicality, scientificity, and importance of the manuscript, including the following contents: (1) whether the content of the manuscript is novel and has publication value; (2) Whether the content of the article is objective and true, and whether the experimental data can withstand verification; (3) Whether the discourse is objective and fair, and whether the arguments and evidence are rigorous and sufficient; (4) Whether the discussion and conclusion are reasonable; (5) Is the citation of references necessary and reasonable; (6) Whether the use of text expression and charts is appropriate; (7) Provide revision suggestions for errors, structures, etc. in the text; wait.
